What had landed in Snyder’s tray? It seemed a defixio, an ancient curse tablet. 1
In Snyder’s analysis, Stripling and many of their experienced associates concurred. Why? These they had often seen. From the Greco-Roman world, they are common archaeological finds. 2
Still, they also recognized the irony. 3 They found this in Deuteronomy’s “Mountain of Curses!” 4
Stripling also understood that this artifact posed a problem. Zertal dated the altar site from 1400 to 1250 B.C. He concluded this from careful pottery analysis. But Stripling knew that defixios dated to the Greek and Roman eras. 5 That is primarily from the fourth century B.C. onward. A curse tablet appeared as an anachronism of around a millennium.
He, however, was aware of a precedent.
The Book of Job speaks of Job’s desire to write on lead with an iron pen (Job 19:24).
Many scholars consider that book the oldest biblical text. One reason is that it does not allude to the Law of Moses. 6
Glyphs adorned the tablet’s exterior. Stripling realized this. Yet he was most intrigued by what lay within. As with other defixios, someone likely inscribed a curse there.
Usually, this curse was trivial. Often, it was something like, “She stole my boyfriend. May her hair fall out.” 1
Stripling and a colleague thus attempted to open it. The lead of one corner, brittle with age, crumbled. They thus stopped further efforts. 2
The Hebrew University of Tel Aviv analyzed the lead fragments and determined their origin. It was from a mine in Lavrion, Greece. 3
Historians and archaeologists conclude that this mine indeed exported lead to the Middle East. This occurred from before the Late Bronze Age to Roman times. 4
Here, a curious historical anomaly deserves consideration.
In the Mediterranean world around the 12th century B.C., a dark age ensued. Then, the Late Bronze Age civilization imploded. Ancient exports plunged. European / Asian economic and cultural sophistication wilted. A mysterious disaster struck several advanced societies. These included the Hittite, Ugaritic, Minoan, Mycenaean, Trojan, and Babylonian. Scholars have yet to find a definitive explanation. 5
From this understanding, Stripling deduced a probability.
Zertal’s exhaustive study had found only pottery of the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries.
Someone in the thirteenth century B.C. or earlier thus likely imported the lead tablet before the ancient Dark Age of 1200 to 1150 B.C. 6
The metallurgical analysis, thus, strengthened Stripling’s tablet date.
This, however, was not concrete.
Stripling felt that the tablet investigation should end. Tablet leads seemed exhausted. It was time to focus on his other pursuits.
He emailed a colleague a photo of the tablet.
Afterwards, this circulated online.
Later, an unexpected opportunity for further investigation materialized.
Stripling read about a technological advancement. Researchers in Europe demonstrated how to peer through lead to discern written content. They were from the Institute of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics (Telč, Czech Republic). 7
Stripling and others went to work. Israeli authorities issued a license. A colleague would courier the “defixio” to Prague. 8
Time passed. The Institute at Telč, 152 km from the Czech capital, finished its analysis. They then forwarded their results. 9
The Telč team indeed perceived something within. An epigraphic expert there suggested proto-alphabetic letters. Ancient letters represented sounds rather than complete thoughts.
From these initial findings, Stripling discerned much. Now, he had his most conclusive evidence for dating the tablet. It had to be the Late Bronze Age or Early Iron Age I, from as early as 1400 to as late as 1250 B.C.
Why? This was the accepted period for proto-alphabetic script. 10
The tablet no longer presented an anachronistic dilemma. It now matched Zertal’s pottery dates.
What else could this tomographic evidence reveal?
I probe this further in my next post!
But now here is a question: What do you think likely caused the Late Bronze Age civilizational collapse?
Let me know in the comments below.
Next post: “Staking a Claim”
Sean McDowell, Oldest Hebrew Writing? Mt. Ebal Curse Tablet (Revisited) m.youtube.com>watch, (8:49), 11 May 2023. ↩︎
Sean McDowell, Oldest Hebrew Writing? Mt. Ebal Curse Tablet (Revisited) m.youtube.com>watch, (39:34 and 40:38), 11 May 2023; and Associates for Biblical Research, “ABR Researchers Discover the Oldest Known Proto-Hebrew Inscription Ever Found”, biblicarchaeology.org/current-events-list/, Youtube, (08:08), March 24, 2022; and Associates for Biblical Research, Cursed! The Mount Ebal Curse Tablet (Part Two, Digging for Truth Episode 200), YouTube, (14:35), May 1, 2023. ↩︎
Associates for Biblical Research, Cursed! The Mount Ebal Curse Tablet (Part Two, Digging for Truth Episode 200), YouTube, (15:00), May 1, 2023. ↩︎
Sean McDowell, Oldest Hebrew Writing? Mt. Ebal Curse Tablet (Revisited) m.youtube.com>watch, (14:28 and 24:09), 11 May 2023 ↩︎
To view this memorandum from the beginning, click here.
From the tomographic scans, Stripling’s epigraphers discerned words.
These included “Yahweh” and “cursed”. Both recall Joshua’s ceremony of blessings and curses on Mt. Gerizim and Mt. Ebal.
Dr. Gershon Galil of the University of Haifa added further. He decoded a sophisticated parallelism, a chiasmus. 1
You will find this literary device throughout the Old and New Testaments. Consider, for example, Luke 4:16b-20, “The Favorable Year of the Lord”. 2
The colors highlight the parallels; the large font is a central focus:
14 And Jesus returned to Galilee in the power of the Spirit, and news about Him spread through all the surrounding district. 15 And He began teaching in their synagogues and was praised by all. 16 And He came to Nazareth, where He had been brought up, and as was His custom,
He entered the synagogue on the Sabbath,
and stood up to read,
17 And the book of the prophet
Isaiah was handed to Him,
And He opened the book and
found the place
where it was written,
18 “The Spirit of the Lord is upon Me
Because He anointed Me to
preach the gospel to the poor.
He has sent Me to proclaim
release / to the captives,
And recovery of sight tothe blind,
To set free / those who
are oppressed,
19 To proclaim the
favorable year of the Lord”
20 And He closed the book,
gave it back to the attendant
and sat down
and the eyes of all in the synagogue were fixed on Him.
21 And He began to say to them, “Today this Scripture has been fulfilled in your hearing.”
But life threw Stripling a curveball, mandating a different approach. 4
Speculation circulated about the photo that Stripling had emailed earlier. 5 The associate had forwarded it. Recipients began generating noise online. Some pondered the tablet’s glyphs. Could they be a script?
This alarmed Stripling. Others might lay academic claim to the tablet’s message, he thought. 6 He thus deemed it necessary to go public. Otherwise, he risked forfeiting his claim as the head archaeologist of the discovering team. 7
A press conference ensued in March 2022. At it, Stripling and his team announced the following: 8
The lead defixio found by his team contained archaic proto-alphabetic script;
From forty letters, the Hebrew name for God appears twice, and the word “cursed” ten times;
The tablet dates to the late Bronze Age, making it two to four hundred years older than any other known Hebrew text.
A reading may be a chiasmus, a literary form employed in both the Old and New Testaments.
That proposed reading was:
Cursed, cursed, cursed-cursed by the God YHW You will die cursed. Cursed you will surely die. Cursed by YHW-cursed, cursed, cursed! 1
(Mt. Ebal “Curse Tablet” Full Press Conference, YouTube, Appian Media, March 29, 2022)
Afterwards, public elation and scorn followed.
Why scorn?
In our next post, entitled “A Firestorm”, I address this.
I look forward to continuing with you.
Now, here is a question. What is your favorite chiasmus, scriptural or otherwise? (See examples here.)
Respond in the comment section below.
Next post: “A Firestorm!”
Sean McDowell, Oldest Hebrew Writing? Mt. Ebal Curse Tablet (Revisited) m.youtube.com>watch, (17:08), 11 May 2023. ↩︎
L. J. Hooge, “The Favorable Year of the Lord”, Biblical Chiasmus, Discovering and Exploring Reverse Parallelism in the Bible, https://biblicalchiasmus.wordpress.com/, August 3, 2014. ↩︎
Sean McDowell, Oldest Hebrew Writing? Mt. Ebal Curse Tablet (Revisited) m.youtube.com>watch, (25:00), 11 May 2023. ↩︎
Associates for Biblical Research, “ABR Researchers Discover the Oldest Known Proto-Hebrew Inscription Ever Found”, biblicarchaeology.org/current-events-list/, YouTube, March 24, 2022. ↩︎
Why the intense scorn about Stripling’s pronouncement about the Curse Tablet?
The archaeological community acknowledged a procedure. It discouraged reporting a find until after it had completed peer review. Stripling admitted to violating this.
About this infraction, Stripling explained that he had feared losing his intellectual stake. He thus felt compelled, despite protocol, to release what he had.
Unfortunately, this happened after another archaeological embarrassment. This heightened sensitivity about procedures. 1
The Israel Antiquities Authority had publicized its analysis of a Tel Lachish sherd. Their news release heralded it as a first. Before this, no find in Israel had referenced Darius the Great, the Persian king of 2500 years ago. 2
The tomb of Darius the Great (550 B.C. to 486 B.C.) at Naqsh-e-Rustam The site lies northwest of ancient Persepolis, 30 miles (50 km) northeast of modern Shiraz, Iran.
Photo by Nursel Kaya on Pexels.com Ruins of Persepolis, a city founded by Darius the Great
Shortly afterwards, however, a researcher specializing in ancient Aramaic confessed. She had written the inscription.
While visiting the site with her students, she demonstrated the ancient script on a sherd. After finishing her lesson, she tossed it aside without malice. 3
What she had demonstrated was accurate. In fact, it fooled renowned scholars.
Mortification ensued across prestigious academic communities.
This outraged many scholars. Stripling’s alleged that his photographs challenged history. He had not undergone peer review, nor released his photos for academic scrutiny. This prevented the immediate vetting of his claims.
Stripling had lit a firestorm!
Now, here are some questions. Should archaeologists always wait until after peer review to release information about a discovery? Why or why not?
Why? The scientific community needed to regard the journal. 2 Interpreting this artifact required complex computer analysis. It also necessitated archaeological and epigraphic expertise.
After Stripling’s team submitted their paper, the journal engaged three reviewers. These, they discerned, had appropriate backgrounds. 3
The reviewers assessed the presentation’s credibility and identified where it needed strengthening. Afterwards, they drafted questions, comments, etc.
Stripling welcomed the reviewers’ initial views and queries.
Two of the reviewers gave glowing approval.
The other reflected considerable disdain. In fact, that person suggested criminality. 4
All three, however, praised the writing and scholarship.
Each had inquiries. Seventy-two requests for modifications or clarifications followed.
Stripling and his team responded.
Afterwards, the two reviewers’ favorable remarks continued. They recommended publication.
On receiving the Stripling team’s responses, the dissenting panel member’s negativity softened. They had received legal clarification from Israel and the West Bank.
The result: the reviewers unanimously recommended publication. 5
(Note that Heritage Science has not released the names of the peer reviewers.) 6
The journal published the Stripling team’s article. 7
Soon, I will examine that publication.
The next post, however, puts these days into perspective. Following that, I will return to Stripling’s Heritage Science piece.
Here is a question. In an interview, Dr. Stripling stated, “The goal of archaeology is not excavation. It’s publication!” Why do you think this is true? 8
Here is our final history post. While all the previous ones are important, this is especially so!
Twelve months elapsed after the press conference. Then, on 12 May 2023, Heritage Science finally published Stripling’s article. That is three and a half years from the tablet’s discovery.
How was that article received?
Some people expressed elation, some disappointment, and others disgust.
Later, I will scrutinize the article, its photos, and various responses.
Here, though, I recall the context of these days. Significant currents darkened the times from the tablet’s discovery through Stripling’s publication and beyond.
Of these, three particularly warrant recounting.
Pandemic
In December 2019, the lead tablet landed in Frankie Snyder’s wet-sifting tray.
Ominous events brewed elsewhere.
The date is December 12, 2019. On that date, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recorded this diary entry:
“A cluster of patients in China’s Hubei Province, in the city of Wuhan, begin to experience the symptoms of an atypical pneumonia-like illness that does not respond well to standard treatments.”
Afterwards, COVID-19 led to a two-year hiatus from Stripling’s work in Israel. 1
Local Perils
On January 24, 2023, Jewish News Syndicate, JNS, reported an Israeli official’s protest. The Israeli Defense Minister, Yoav Gallant, communicated:
“Israel will not allow Palestinians to damage a major archaeological site located deep in the biblical heartland of Samaria, one that is revered by millions of Jews and Christians as the location where Joshua built an altar.”
He issued it in response to a news report. The Palestinian Authority had approved plans for constructing a road and housing near the Ebal altar site.
In a letter to the Palestinian Authority, Gallant further directed:
“…it has been clarified…to the Palestinian Authority that we will not allow any damage to the altar, which has been defined as an archaeological site of historic, cultural and religious significance.”
Past and present events underscored the necessity of Gallant’s manifesto. These include:
In 2021, a Palestinian road crew damaged the outer “footprint” enclosing the Ebal altar.
During recent decades, alarming incidents have occurred in Nablus. This included the firebombing of the alleged tomb of the patriarch, Joseph. (Note that the actual location of Joseph’s tomb is a matter of speculation.)
Now, armed military units escort pilgrims to the area. This began after the Oslo Accords. They designated the region as “Area B”. Authority there rested with the Palestinian civil government and the Israeli military.
From this last bullet, one can sense what locals might feel. Some descend from generations of residents. This would aggrieve many.
If this Israeli military escort resembles an American operation, I can envision its composition. Vehicles arrive armed with 50-caliber machine guns, 240 Bravos, or 249 SAWS. Infantry clad in full armor climb to elevated positions. A defensive cordon restricts unauthorized civilians from entering the area.
If some foreign authority exercised such power near my home, I imagine my caustic feelings!
One can also perceive the necessity of these escort measures.
Thus, factor in local embitterment when evaluating the security of the altar site.
October 7, 2023
Little, if anything, equates to the ghastly evil of Hamas’s massacre of innocents on this date.
Whether one labels Israel’s response “hard” or “brutal” is not the question. Both can fall well within the acceptable context of the laws of war.
The real question is whether Israel has perpetrated war crimes. This, world authorities must judge. Where necessary, soldiers, units, and leaders must give an account.
Two things can be true. Violations of the law of war we should not excuse. One should also not forget the horror that precipitated the resulting conflagration.
For our purposes, we must remember this: Mt. Ebal lies proximate to the eye of this tumult.
Let us now bridge these troubled waters.
In the next post, I will begin my review of the Stripling team’s Heritage Science article.
Here are questions: Do you remember first hearing about COVID-19? Where and when was this? Are you aware that in 1918, a flu likely originated near Fort Riley, Kansas? That one, in short order, killed between twenty and a hundred million people worldwide. Many agree that it hastened the end of World War I and exasperated tensions that led to World War II.
Let me know in the comments.
Thank you for engaging with this topic!
We move on from our history. The next fact category concerns Stripling’s claims. After that comes the last fact category: “Opposing claims.”
I look forward to continuing with you.
If you appreciate this type of analysis, please “subscribe”, “like”, and “share”.
To support this work, you can donate below. If so, thank you for the encouragement.
Heritage Science finally published its Curse Tablet article on 12 May 2023. Twelve months had passed since Stripling’s press conference; three years since discovery.
The article’s body states the ideas Stripling considered. In the conclusion, however, he establishes his stance. There, he counters the idea that Moses could not have authored the Torah.
The article credits team member Professor Gershon Galil. He directs the Institute of Biblical and Ancient History at the University of Haifa. He deciphered most of the tablet’s interior face.
The article outlines Galil’s premises. It cites his increased letter count. The forty declared at the press conference went to forty-eight at publication. 1 The article also acknowledges his modified chiasmus.
Yet note a crucial point. The article’s conclusion leaves many, if not most, of Galil’s premises orphaned. For example, it neither adopts nor rejects his accounting of tablet letters. The same applies to his full chiasmus interpretation.
Instead, it concludes that the tablet’s inscription challenges history for truncated reasons. Those include:
The tablet displays in proto-alphabetic script the word “YHW”, the name of the Hebrew God;
We thus know that a Hebrew inscribed the tablet before 1250 B.C.
Additionally, the tablet contains the word “ARWR,” or “cursed.”
These words recall events described in Deuteronomy and the Book of Joshua;
Thus, this artifact challenges the historical paradigm.
The note immediately following the conclusion is telling. It acknowledges Galil’s allegiance to his premises. It announces that he desires to stand firm on his specific tablet reading. 2
Stripling, however, adopted a more conservative approach. 3
After publication, Galil and Stripling ended their affiliation. This they did on amicable terms.
What are the consequences of this?
For us, Stripling has simplified our original question, “Is there anything to see here?”
Stripling’s team answers with a resounding “Yes!” They point to the two words inside this artifact. There you find the ancient Hebrew ‘cursed’ and ‘Yahweh’. They, alone with the tablet’s setting, challenge world history!
This makes our photo study easier.
From Stripling’s perspective, we can focus on photos relevant to two words. The other words of Galil’s chiasmus are an important conjecture. But they are not crucial to Stripling’s conclusion.
Observation Two
Our study reviews more than the Stripling article and its photos. We also probe another article.
Whose article is this? It is by Mark S. Haughwout, the scholar I mentioned earlier in the post “Journey Essentials”.
Heritage Science also published his article allegedly refuting Stripling’s tablet claims.
That article disputes the words for “cursed” and “Yahweh”.
Additionally, it objects to the Hebrew word for “You will die!” and two letters.
This word and the additional letters are included in our study.
Observation Three
In the proto-alphabetic era, writing followed boustrophedon paths. 4 No standardized script existed. Instead, letters tracked like oxen plowing. Envision a pre-teen or an inebriated adult pushing a lawnmower.
Here we examine the first photos of our Curse Tablet.
From tomographic scans, we assess an intimidating word. That is “ARWR” or “cursed”. This is one of the two words fundamental to Stripling’s conclusion.
Gershon Galil has identified “ARWR” six times on the tablet’s inner face. We will focus on only one.
(Afterwards, click on the underscores to link photos, drawings, charts, etc.)
Galil sketched the tablet’s inner symbols. See Figure 7.
“Resh” often resembles a rhombus. Sometimes, though, it has a tail, making it resemble a kite.
One can confuse “Waw” and “Resh”. But “Waw” replicates a mace, a heavy blunt object with a sturdy handle. A combatant used it to bash an enemy’s skull, bones, and armor. It can also be an ornate symbol of authority.
Note that the photos of Tables 2-9 mirror the drawings in Figure 7. You must view one in a mirror for them to correspond. Otherwise, they appear backwards.
Now see Table 10. It reveals several photos of “Outer B”, the tablet’s bottom.
Galil alleges that this sacred name appears twice inside the tablet.
For simplicity, I discuss only one of those here. I call that “Upper Yahweh” because those letters lie near the top of the tablet.
Galil’s annotated Table 7 labels them as numbers: 11, 12, and 13.
The phonetic spelling is thus “Yod,” “He,” “Waw”. 1
They look like this:
My beach towel’s Egyptian hieroglyphic imitates proto-alphabetic “Yod”. Photo by Pixabay on Pexels.com Photo by Bismad Shots on Pexels.com
An angled arm symbolizes “Yod”. Picture it running from above the elbow to the thumb and then to the fingertips. See Figure 7, #11, and Table 5 (1a and 1 b).
A stickman with raised arms, as if signaling a touchdown, signifies “He”. See Figure 7, #12, in Table 3 (1a & b). Here, “He” stands. Note, however, that you also find it seated. 2 See Figure 7, # 40, in Table 3 (3a & b).
“Waw” is the blunt-force weapon and symbol of authority described above. See Figure 7, #13, in Table 4 (1a & b). Also view the alleged negative bulge in Table 10, photo #4.
The wrist and forearm below the left leg of “Heh”; and
An upper arm extends at a right angle from “Heh’s” left ankle.
This photo from Haughwont’s article gives a mirrored view. See Figure 5.
You should study Table 10, photo # 3. The Stripling team argues that this depicts the bottom bulge of this “Yod”.
Do you agree?
That concludes my introduction to the two words that compel Stripling’s conclusions. That is “ARWR” and “YHW.”
Read these sections several times. Let the photos sink in. 4
With the following post, I complete an initial dive into the tablet’s photos. There, I look at a word and two other letters relevant to Haughwout’s arguments.
Later, however, I will delve deeper into the words and symbols mentioned above.
Now for a question: What impact do the bottom bulges have on your assessment of Stripling’s claims?
We now finish our initial canvas of letters and words.
Our lexicon consists of: “ARWR”, “YHW”, and “TMT.”
We have learned seven letters: “Aleph”, “He”, “Mem”, “Resh”, “Taw”, “Waw”, and “Yod”.
The thought of tackling ancient inscriptions was likely intimidating. In retrospect, they are straightforward.
But this I find a wonder. With relative ease, first graders learn all 26 letters of our alphabet. Plus, they master a host of words from their readers. Wow!