The Mt. Ebal Curse Tablet
Decision
[Ebal, twenty-eight of thirty-four]
Has Haughwout refuted Stripling’s claims? Here is my decision!

Haughwout’s conclusion states:
“The only substantiated claim that Stripling et al. can make at this time is that they have found a very old, small piece of folded lead on Mt. Ebal using wet sifting.”
Thus, Haughwout claims to have disproved Stripling’s assertions.
I measure this claim against a standard set out by the U.S. Supreme Court. That rule governs summary judgment in our federal system.
To decide for Haughwout, I must reach a specific finding. It is that a reasonable person could not genuinely dispute the material fact(s) of his claim. If I discover otherwise, I must reject his claim.
Further, I condensed Haughwout’s claim to a singular material fact. It is that: At least one of the following statements is true:
- The tablet does not depict the words “ARWR” and “YHW” in proto-alphabetic script, or
- A Hebrew before 1250 B.C. did not inscribe the tablet.
A reasonable person could genuinely dispute this statement.
Haughwout thus failed in his refutation.
Here is a list of points that support my adjudication:
- Likely, Hebrews of the proto-alphabetic era wrote “Yahweh” with three letters. Egyptians contemporary with Moses may have written it the same. They may, however, have added another symbol to capture a final vowel. Hebrew scribes later shifted from three to four letters. They added the “He” to capture the previously understood vowel ending, in this case, an “eh” sound.
- A scribe used “Waw” in place of the vowel in “ARUR”. Here is why:
- The substitution makes phonetic sense.
- Also, the evidence suggests that this Late Bronze Age spelling persisted. The example is the eighth century B.C., Tomb of Shebnayahu.
- The crack lines of Aleph (Figure 7, #25, and Table 2, (3a & b) do not make a smooth intersection with the horns. Thus, it is reasonable to deduce that the cracks intersect with the well-drawn figure.
- Affiliating the artifact with the Mountain of Curses is reasonable. A scriptural scenario makes better sense than the alternatives. This artifact is likely not a net sinker, hair adornment, or theatre ticket. The scriptural attribution fits the provenance.
- A reasonable person can see both the “Yod” and the “Waw” of Upper Yahweh. The “He” a child can see.
- Further, that person can consider tiny letters consequential. This, they can relate to other tiny inscriptions. One example is a wedding ring inscription.
- A reasonable person can find the tablet’s boustrophedon track appropriate. The inscriber may have meant it only for God’s eyes. Now, it makes sense to men.
- Additionally, the tablet’s bottom bulges show evidence of proto-alphabetic letters inside. The upper “YHW’s” head dot and the protrusion of “Dancing He” exemplify this. As do others.
- Furthermore, part of Haughwout’s criticisms do more to strengthen Stripling’s conclusions. Again, he acknowledges that proto-alphabetic letters would date the tablet to 1250 to 1400 B.C. He later acknowledges that “TMT” (Figure 7, # 18, 19 & 20) is a proto-alphabetic word.
Despite the above, I conclude that Haughwout’s criticisms significantly advance scholarly debate. That includes where he errs. Why? Such clearly stated, academically advanced reasoning engenders a healthy scientific and scholarly exchange.
The stark exception is the claim of a “refutation/ disproval”.
He should have represented his work as a “denial” of Stripling’s claims.
This mischaracterization can harm science and scholarship. It can deflect further excavation, quench funding, and block permits.
It hinders the truth.
Thus, I deny Haughwout’s “refutation”.

Photo by Pixabay on Pexels.com
Stripling’s article is thus “safe!” Haughwout’s “refutation” tag does not apply.
This memorandum’s next section is titled “Follow Through.” It addresses how to apply my decision.
But beforehand, here are some questions: Do you agree with my decision? Why or why not?
Let me know in the comments section below.
Thank you for engaging with this topic thus far!
The next post is: “Last Legs”
I look forward to continuing with you there.
If you appreciate this type of analysis, please “subscribe”, “like”, and “share”.
To support this work, you can donate below. If so, thank you for the encouragement.
Next post: “Last Leg”
Make a one-time donation
Make a monthly donation
Make a yearly donation
Choose an amount
Or enter a custom amount
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.

To view this memorandum from the beginning, click here.

Leave a Reply